Jody Lipford and Bruce Yandle wonder why everybody’s fussing about the need for climate change legislation, arguing that past experience with other pollutants suggests that the best way to mobilize public efforts on environmental issues is to maximize economic growth. They’re right about dirty air, which is a local phenomenon. But it’s hard to see why folks will ever be sufficiently motivated to reduce local carbon emissions without financial incentives, since the effects will largely be felt far away – and far in the future.







Jody Lipford and I thank you for calling attention to our work on carbon emissions and environmental Kuznets curves. Our underlying research paper to which you refer implicitly, “Environmental Kuznets Curves, Carbon Emissions, and Public Choice,” is forthcoming in Environment and Development Economics. Upon reading the paper and rereading our piece in Regulation, we think you may find that you have mischaracterized our understanding of the nature of local versus global emission control.
All best wishes.
Bruce Yandle